User blog comment:OneTwoSix/Club Penguin Ruined Rare./@comment-5055839-20130105193650

Why you cares about a item being rare or not? Same goes to Life Vest in the Rockhopper's Quest or the Blue Propeller Cap from April Fools' 2007 being available at 2009 and 2012. The game doesn't have the name "Club Rare", and the description of the game doesn't says: "This is a game where a item from 2007 never returns". The game have the name "Club Penguin" and the description of the game says: "Have fun and meet new friends." Like Dever said, rarity doesn't matter.