Board Thread:Club Penguin/@comment-69.123.9.25-20130312194038/@comment-65.33.188.53-20130329132438

It is a fairly uncommon item, but not quite "rare" yet. Items listed as rare are from 2008 or earlier, but many items that haven't returned since 2009 are close to being part of that group. Being placed in the gift shop along with other rare items may hint that it is not coming back ever, and thus will become rare, but that is not certain. Many rare penguins don't view that item as rare, but you could show it off to newer members as rare...