Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6490183-20130708183610/@comment-16245405-20131005103130

I don't think Disney should return the rare items. It would be selfish for those who actually got it legitimately in 2005 - 2009. (those were the rare years) Plus it would make rare penguins upset. They might as well joined today. It makes them look like nothing if rare items came back. I myself have lots of rare items, and I think it should stay that way. The final point is, if they come back, there not rare anymore. So they might as well be new items. The only 2 types of items that are 100% not coming back are Party Hats and Pins.