User blog comment:AnonymousDuckLover/Club Penguin Island Review/@comment-25300287-20170513200833/@comment-5814264-20170513202337

This game has redeemable qualities, and rating it poorly just because it is likely the main reason CP Classic no longer exists isn't a fair way of reviewing it. When rating something, I try to look at it objectively, and to do that, I can't look at the story behind it, but instead I have to look at what it is.

For example, I'm not going to give Rick Astley's "Never Gonna Give You Up" a good review score based on the fact you can troll people quite well with it by telling them they'll be getting one thing, and then giving them another. Listening to this song, ignoring the fact that this song is a meme that will never die, I'd probably give the song a 4/10 due to its cliched nature, and repetitive pop lyrics, despite the fact the song is amazing.