Board Thread:Club Penguin/@comment-24888747-20140521165556/@comment-25396835-20140820194941

Herbert wouldnt sink it. The only reason it almost sunk was on accident. And it shouldnt even have created the hole through the island it did since the lower half of the island is composed of solid earth for who knows why. Heat wouldnt be able to break through rock unless it was from something of extremely high temperatures like the sun. Besides... even if that somehow did happen I think it would be in best interest to try and bring the island back up. They have the ability to do so and if they didnt every single penguin on Club Penguin island basically would have to start their lives fresh.

Not only that but the CP team would never do it. Club Penguin island sinking = end of CP. They would never do that.