Board Thread:Club Penguin/@comment-28166533-20160716095220/@comment-4958019-20160717204004

Personally, I like both rooms. In the case of the Stage, I like how CP made a igloo based off it, yet it isn't the same. I liked seeing many plays return to CP. Unfortunately, the Stage was really bugged in its last few days and I disliked that, especially because CP knew about it and did not do anything to fix the bugs. I actually liked the interactivity in certain plays, like Space Adventure, Ruby and the Ruby, Secrets of the Bamboo Forest, among others. However, it felt very old after CP kept bringing many plays without any few changes. I feel like CP should've made new plays.

As for the Mall, I like it as well, but dislike how there isn't much to do. I find it a great spot to hangout with other players on CP, but just like the Stage, it doesn't have much interactivity with it. The Mall had a great potential to offer a lot, yet CP didn't think enough of the room. I like how the Costume Trunk is still present in the room though.

In my opinion, CP should've kept both rooms. Frankly, I have no idea why CP even decides to close rooms, I mean, I'm sure it doesn't do much harm to them, yet offer players a bigger island to explore. The Ninja Hideout could've stayed after the May 2013 renovation in the Dojo (inside and outside), the Recycle Plant could've after the July 2013 renovation in the Mine Shack. Unless a certain room had an interesting story to cause such room to close (or renovate) (for instance, the Sports Shop and the PSA HQ), I find it useless to close any room.

A good alternative to offer players a closed room is to make it become into an igloo. I can see a Ninja Hideout Igloo and a Recycle Plant Igloo work.

In conclusion, CP should've kept both rooms and if not, at least offer more to the Mall.