Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-7033565-20150325024034/@comment-25610519-20150403101431

Eclipse-Magician wrote: Octopushy wrote: Eclipse-Magician wrote: Octopushy wrote: Eclipse-Magician wrote: Octopushy wrote: Eclipse-Magician wrote: Grand Moff Birdin wrote: Eclipse-Magician wrote: That is very interesting, but the thing is... Herbert doesn't like penguins. LOL.

And also, if Herbert could've gotton to a warmer place, then he would be at peace. His main motive is quiet and warmth.

But by all means, I'm interested to hear more of this. Do you mind elaborating? Well he requites penguins because it's easier to be an equal opportunity guy. also he still torments(albeit in silly ways) club penguin because it's fun (except for blowing up takeovers he considers that a break from being evil)

Not really challenging this idea, but how so? Last time I checked, Herbert isn't that evil. isn't that evil

Operation Blackout, it exists.

Really? I thought he was just overly-selfish. A mixture of both, I presume.

Evil and overly-selfish. Definitely villain material. But if so, how can penguins work for him? That's where the flaw in his plan (excluding the player's penguin) hit hard, Herbert probably didn't think of that. Not to mention:

If Herbert hogs all the sunlight to himself, it would be too cold for plant life to grow, and we know Herbert is a vegetarian, eventually, he too, would die.

That's really harsh for a kids' game, but I think Herbert can pull off an indoor garden.

So basically the island ends up dying or his 'minions' rebel? Yeah, a indoor garden would keep HERBERT alive. The most natural food source for Penguins is fish (as said by G in the 2nd PSA mission) so penguins die out. Same with Puffles.

Yeah, so either way, Herbert couldn't make the penguins obey him.