Gray Goodies stamp

The Gray Goodies stamp is a members-only hard difficulty stamp in Club Penguin. All members can earn this stamp by catching 15 gray fish in the game Ice Fishing.

Trivia

 * Since the only known way to catch a Gray Fish is to wear a Flashing Lure Fishing Rod in the Game Upgrades of the game, and the rod is currently only available to members, this means that only members are able to catch gray fish and thus earn this stamp.
 * Gray fish are more difficult and trickier to catch than the yellow ones. This explains why this stamp is a hard difficulty one.
 * However, some members who often play the game still think that this stamp should be considered a medium or even easy difficulty one, not a hard one.