Club Penguin Wiki:Demotion Project

The Demotion Project is a place where any user can vote on users to be demoted.

Rules and how to nominate


 * Rules


 * You can not vote for or against yourself.
 * You must have made at least 20 edits this month.
 * A user that was nominated for demotion cannot be nominated again in the following month.
 * A vote closes after 2 weeks.
 * How to nominate a user


 * 1) Contact an admin and mention the nominee's username. Tell the admin why you believe a demotion should be done.
 * 2) This admin will then confirm whether it's a reason for demotion. If possible, it's also recommended that 2 admins will confirm it.
 * Nominating

To nominate, paste the following text in the bottom of the page and fill in the parameters

(0)

 * Nominated by and confirmed by 

Comments

 *  - the nominee for demotion.
 *  - the name of the person that request the demotion.
 * - the name of the confirming admin(s).
 *  - the reason for demotion.
 * Voting

Vote under the "For" section if you want to vote for, and sign under the "Against" section if you vote against. Signing is done by adding to the bottom of the list of votes: #~ Your signature must contain your user name and/or a link to your use page (or user talk or contributions).

Remember to change the number of votes in the heading when voting.

Please vote under this line

JWPengie (+3)

 * Nominated and confirmed by Kallie Jo

He is very active, but he has not used his rollback right since April 23rd. Why should he continue to have rights he's not using? This nomination would demote him to chat moderator.

For (5)

 * 1) Kallie Jo   (talk)  03:08, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * 2) F u r r y H a m s t e r 0 3  Puffle 2014 Transformation Player Card Rainbow.png  03:10, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * 3)  ~ Perapin   (Contact)   03:12, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * 4) Callum Fawsitt
 * 5) OrangePuffleApr2014PengStyleCatPose.png I steal your cake!   Problem?  BirthdayCakewithCandles.png 09:55, July 19, 2014 (UTC)

Against (2)

 * 1) Record_Pin.PNG Let's;   Start;   The;   Music! Green_Headphones_icon.png 09:58, July 19, 2014 (UTC)
 * 2) (Unknown's My Name Robbing's My Game 10:15, July 19, 2014 (UTC)

Comments

 * Agreed. The rollback right is for people that need the rollback tool, which JWPengie doesn't often use. He makes a great chat moderator though. :)  ~ Perapin   (Contact)   03:12, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * I agree with Perapin. JWPengie is a good CM! F u r r y H a m s t e r 0 3  Puffle 2014 Transformation Player Card Rainbow.png  03:14, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * I think we should have notified JWPengie before demoting him right away. --Rowboat Pin.PNGtalk 03:16, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * Huh? We aren't demoting him right away. It's clear he hasn't been using his rights (he's had 3 months to show it.) Kallie Jo   (talk)  03:21, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * I mean, like, send him a message that we are holding a demotion vote against him. Also, this is the first time someone attempts to demote a rollback not because of inactivity, but because a lack of usage of the rollback right. So, I think it is reasonable to send him a message to tell him the changes in the demotion criteria. --Rowboat Pin.PNGtalk 03:25, July 18, 2014 (UTC)
 * NO! Just No! Who would wanna demote JW? I'm voting against, i don't care if he isn't 'using his rights', he may be a good CM but i think he should stay where he is (Unknown's My Name Robbing's My Game 10:15, July 19, 2014 (UTC)