Club Penguin Wiki:Demotion Project

The Demotion Project is a place where any user can vote on users to be demoted.

Rules and how to nominate


 * Rules


 * You cannot vote for or against yourself.
 * You cannot tell other users to vote for or against someone, including if you are nominated.
 * You must have made at least 20 mainspace edits this month.
 * A user that was nominated for demotion cannot be nominated again in the following month.
 * A vote closes after 2 weeks.
 * How to nominate a user


 * 1) Contact an admin and mention the nominee's username. Tell the admin why you believe a demotion should be done.
 * 2) This admin will then confirm whether it's a reason for demotion. If possible, it's also recommended that 2 admins will confirm it.
 * Nominating

To nominate, paste the following text in the bottom of the page and fill in the parameters

(0)

 * Nominated by and confirmed by 

Comments

 *  - the nominee for demotion.
 *  - the name of the person that request the demotion.
 * - the name of the confirming admin(s).
 *  - the reason for demotion.
 * Voting

Vote under the "For" section if you want to vote for, and sign under the "Against" section if you vote against. Signing is done by adding to the bottom of the list of votes: #~ Your signature must contain your user name and/or a link to your use page (or user talk or contributions).

Remember to change the number of votes in the heading when voting.

Please vote under this line

Techman129 (-1)

 * Nominated by TheNintendoKing and confirmed by Callum Fawsitt. (Vote ends July 13).

He is a strange mod. I will not be going through the logs, I am going to let others do that because I cannot be bothered. Either way, he kicks people far too many times for invalid reasons such as his own opinions. For example, one time I saw him come onto chat and I said; '* TheNintendoKing bullies Techman (evil)'. And he kicked me for that ;_;. Like what the hell. He also kicks many other people for no reason at all and bans many other people for no reason at all. Another point is that whenever someone says something apparently violent, he just makes it sound worse than it actually is. Also, he is quite rude as well. Bunch of other reasons that I will allow other users to point out if they wish.

For (5)

 * 1) --TheNintendoKing
 * 2) --Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 17:32, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * 3) -- Miss Sanrio! 17:36, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * 4) -- Morton Koopa
 * 1) -- Morton Koopa

Against (6)

 * 1) -- FuzzyHamster   talk   17:41, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * 2) --Close to the end of school... What to do? (talk) 17:42, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * 3) -- Austin THE GOAT (talk) 18:03, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * 4) --Llove Kuwait ( Meow! ) ( Meow? ) 14:10, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * 5) Signature Sandor.png(talk) 14:29, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * 6) —Vicyorus (talk) 02:15, July 2, 2015 (UTC)

Comments

 * Yes, his behavior recently has been out of hand. He overreacts when some people wanted him demoted, etc. Also he's been argumentative and annoying to some, so I'm going to support for this nomination for demotion. Miss Sanrio!  17:36, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * Tech doesn't abuse his rights, and I haven't seen any evidence on why he should be demoted I would like to see it.  FuzzyHamster    talk   17:41, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * Since when did mr. Techman abuse his rights? He deserves to not be demoted. He's a good CM, and I can see good things for him in the future. Who in the whole right world suggested this in the first place?!?! Close to the end of school... What to do? (talk) 17:42, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * Lol, just because of the chat incident, he has to be demoted. I find that hilarious.не трябва да излизат тук, моля (talk) 18:03, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * To answer your question, Austin, it wasn't just because of this incident, but a lot of other incidents involving unfair kicks. - User:BellatrixTheMagicalPotato
 * So much favoritism here. Don't go against just cause he's your BFF, especially you, Stickman. Tech has said "shut up" to users as well, (cough, I'm one of them). He has been in arguments with other former and current moderators, such as Callum Fawsitt (now an admin), Chriskim98, and Twinkie102. Now Tech is saying that he wants to die just because his name is on the demotion project. Do you really expect THAT from a moderator? Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 18:26, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * Err.. idk about that. The comments themselves in this section are kinda funny, i gotta admit. Penguin-Pal   (talk)  08:45, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * I've never had a problem with him on chat, so I think he should stay. Signature Sandor.png(talk) 14:29, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * Says the one who barely even comes on chat. Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 22:44, June 30, 2015 (UTC)

Shurow (-2)

 * Nominated by AustinD-3 and confirmed by Callum Fawsitt

Although Shurow is not in violation of the demotion policy, he is rarely active and hardly uses his rights. Thus should be demoted

For (2)

 * 1) не трябва да излизат тук, моля (talk) 23:54, June 29, 2015 (UTC)
 * 2) Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 00:06, June 30, 2015 (UTC)

Against (4)
My page ]]Techman129 [[Special:Editcount/Techman129| Edits ]] 01:49, July 3, 2015 (UTC)
 * 1) Penguin-Pal   (talk)  08:45, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * 2) --FlagBahrain.svg Wolf-gangs ( T a l k )  13:17, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * 20:28, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * 1) [[User:Techman129|

Comments

 * I think I'll stay neutral on this vote. Human-preferences-desktop.svg  C a l l u m F a w s i t t  Human-preferences-desktop.svg   (talk) 00:02, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * Same here.. Miss Sanrio!  00:11, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * Not satisfied with Shurow's activity? Leave him a message. He hasn't been contacted about his activity (at least not via his talk page) for at least a year. I see no reason to start a demotion request so early just because of that. 08:45, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * Yes, but even when he is considered active he still rarely edits.не трябва да излизат тук, моля (talk) 11:48, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * Shurow barely does his job as a admin. Why keep him? He barely comes on chat as well to moderate. New users never get to meet him until a loooonnnggggg time. He doesn't edit as much as he used to. You're not going to leave a admin right here without any active progress just because he your friend, like I said before on the other demotion project. He needs to be demoted, he can redeem himself if he does get demoted. Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 14:07, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * Has anyone even bothered to ask why he's been inactive before jumping straight to trying to demote him? Perhaps he has a reason for that. -- 20:28, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * A reason, of course. So WHAT is the reason? Does the Club Penguin Wikia have to wait a year to find out? He can be away or something, but he has to keep other people aware. Not just pop into chat one by one or make a userpage edit or maybe two mainspace. It can be understood that his name is on the demotion project. I'm sure he was been contacted before, but never responded or had a response that he would be inactive temporarily, but now look where it's at. He has a reason that's not told and doesn't do his job. Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 22:52, June 30, 2015 (UTC)
 * But TNK, There's no reason why shurow even needs to explain why he isn't as active as you might want him to (you aren't extremely active yourself tho :P so it's kinda funny to make that point). If you are not satisfied, you should be the one making the move and ask Shurow- since he hasn't violated any policy. As for "I'm sure he was been contacted before, but never responded"- no, he hasn't been contacted- all messages regarding activity should be sent via the talk page, not via chat or anything- in order to keep track of them. You're welcome to ask him yourself though. If you're impatient, im the meantime, you could get one of those. Penguin-Pal   (talk)  07:13, July 1, 2015 (UTC)
 * TNK hasn't commented prior to your statement, Mr. P-P. TheNintendoKing.
 * I hate this demotion project, I always have. We've lost way too many good admins because of it. I've been inactive because I am away from my usual home for the summer. I'm going to be working soon for a little while so I will be a little more inactive then. It is not my fault I am away. I still care about the wiki, and I would help more if I could, but I can't right now. As for not using my rights, I'm not the only one. There are countless users here on the wiki who simply come here just to chat. Even some of our current staff don't do much anymore, and it's not fair that I should have to be the only one punished for it. Give someone a break for a chance, I can't be here all day every day to help. That's not going to happen. And thank you to those who are understanding *cough Penguin-Pal and Wolf* --United_States_flag.png  S  h  u  r <font color= "Black"> o <font color= "Red"> w Water_Balloon_snowball.png 07:13, July 1, 2015 (UTC)
 * ^ tru ^ sto ^ ry ^ Penguin-Pal   (talk)  07:16, July 1, 2015 (UTC)
 * When was it ever said "Shurow should be active and edit every day"? Anybody would appreciate that but admins have lives Everybody expects from an admin to edit or come on chat. It's not just this year. Last year you were almost classified as inactive. It doesn't matter if you only come on to chat and moderate. Apj26 doesn't edit that often or much, but still nobody has ever thought of demoting him because he's always on chat and a great moderator. It's fine if you are away for a while this summer or whatever. But now you have stated your reason, why couldn't it have been before? It doesn't matter how much you're away or busy, you need to inform the community. Last year and maybe 2013 the same thing happened. Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 20:46, July 1, 2015 (UTC)
 * As the user who added the nomination even stated, he isn't in violation of the Demotion Policy. Therefore, he doesn't "need to inform the community" if he's not violating the policy to begin with. This is seeming like something that could've just been left as a simple talk page message asking about his activity level rather than trying to have him demoted. -- 22:15, July 1, 2015 (UTC)
 * What about before? Just because it's in the past, doesn't mean it's something to forget about. As said before, he was almost classified as inactive last year and he had no vacation or exams. He needs to edit or come on chat when he's free. From 2013 present, there is no way he's away that much, unless if he's in college. He doesn't make much mainspace anymore. It would be acceptable even if he were on chat at least moderating. He just said he doesn't use his rights. He's not a bad admin, but no project. What's the REAL point of Shurow staying as an admin with no progress? You're just causing favoritism, Hey.you. Cheese Pin.png i liek cheez  Cheese Pin.png 17:32, July 2, 2015 (UTC)
 * If commenting with a valid point is "just causing favoritism" by your definition, then by all means. You don't know his situation, and by the look of things, never even cared to ask. -- 18:46, July 2, 2015 (UTC)
 * I think I'll stay neutral on this one. -The magical Potato.
 * More reasonable than a certain someones reasons, but, what is the benefit? We are lower on staff due to many people being too old for CP/losing interest due to declining quality/due to just plain growing up and having more important things to do. Unless someone has absolutely detestable behavior, or is inactive for a considerable amount of time (take Awesome335 for example) I see really no reason for demotion. Again, what is the benefit? It is not like there are dozens of people lining up to be an admin so there is no space really being taken up or anything. Are people not allowed to lives? –Watatsuki sutra scroll Watatsuki sig.png 02:13, July 3, 2015 (UTC)