Club Penguin Wiki:Rollback Promotions

This is a vote page for selecting new Rollbacks.

Please Note!

• You can only vote in the For section for one nominee; all others can be only be voted against.
• To submit a new nominee, please contact one of the admins.
• If you're nominated, you are not allowed to vote against others or for yourself.
• A vote closes one week after the user being nominated.

---

New submissions go under this line

---

Spydar007 (+4)

Nominated and confirmed by Callum Fawsitt.

Spydar007 (talk · blog · contribs · block · logs · block log · rights log)

For (6)

1. April Flowers bloom in patterns! 21:12, April 13, 2015 (UTC)
2. Close to end of school... What to do? (Talk) 15:00, April 14, 2015 (UTC)
3. Callum Fawsitt (talk) 17:48, April 14, 2015 (UTC)
4. Hey.youcp 23:06, April 14, 2015 (UTC)
5. I am Sasquatch's sock! Mwahahahaha 14:06, April 15, 2015 (UTC)
6. File:7th Anniversary Party cake.png7 YEARS ALREADY?! TOO COOL! April 16, 2015

Against (2)

1. TheNintendoKing
2. --Chunky! 14:16, April 18, 2015 (UTC)

Comments

• Spydar007 has been a great contributor over the past few weeks-months. He has a relatively good amount of editing experience too. He's recently been uploading high quality Player Card and In-game images. He's also frequently been undoing edits. I think he'd make a great Rollback. After all, we could do with some new Rollbacks. Callum Fawsitt (talk) 20:53, April 13, 2015 (UTC)
  • Thank you! — Spydar007 (Talk) 14:49, April 14, 2015 (UTC)
• He's very hard working and frequently makes good edits, just saying. April Flowers bloom in patterns! 21:12, April 13, 2015 (UTC)

Read more

He's a good candidate, but this concerns me. Mixing rollback rights with edit warring isn't a good idea. I'll vote "for" only when he starts listening to admins and not adding things to articles before they are confirmed. --Hey.youcp 23:09, April 13, 2015 (UTC) May I just say in my defence the following: I stopped as soon as an admin got involved. In what way was I adding it to an article when it isn't confirmed? I was simply following the way it was done on the other pin pages like the Pop Star Pin and the pages surrounding it. Why should it be different when both pins are unreleased? As soon as Apj told me to stop, I stopped. I do not take "orders" or trust other users (in this case TheNintendoKing), who seem to think they are superior to me, when they aren't; we are actually equal. I had no way of verifying what he was saying. In terms of Watatsuki's edit, as far as I am concerned he made that edit as a user, and not as an admin (if he made it as an admin, does that mean that all edits made by admins are made as admins, and thus nobody can revert any admins edits, even if it is clearly incorrect?). He had not read the discussion I had had with Penguin-Pal on our talk pages, in which we both decided that the pins would be included in the succession boxes, as this is exactly how it was on other pages. If Watatsuki had read the discussion, the whole thing wouldn't have happened. The only reason I engaged in the "edit war" as you so call it, was because what I was doing was simply following what was on the other pages and making them uniform. If Watatsuki had made an addityional edit asking me to stop, I would have done, since that edit would have been made as an admin. I still feel that nobody has actually read the discussion I had with Penguin-Pal, and so they have not seen my reasoning on the situation. Those who haven't can view it here and here. I would also like to point out to you the chat logs surrounding the event. They can be found here, starting at 18:19:35, and ending at 18:35:32. From reading these logs, I get the sense that the admins here are lazy and simply couldn't be bothered to tell me to stop. Do we really want admins who are lazy? Of course, you won't get this from reading this, because you are inclined to side with them, but I am just letting you know what I got from it, and what I feel of the situation. — Spydar007 (Talk) 14:49, April 14, 2015 (UTC) I'm sorry Mr. Man, but you are wrong in every aspect here. P-P is no longer an admin, so, unfortunately, he cannot decide what people edit and what people don't, so the discussion you had really doesn't prove anything. I was completely right in this situation, as Watatsuki had said before it should not be like that. There is no 'admin' edit. An edit is an edit. And when an admin tells you to do something you WILL do it. Apj told you to stop because you had ignored three other users (one being Watatsuki), who had told you to stop. Please do not start edit wars are not listen to admins again. TheNintendoKing I disagree with you there, Tnk. He did help me revert a whole 95 pages of vandalism done by "Roger", and truth to be told, he would be a WAY better Rollback than you, Tnk. Close to end of school... What to do? (Talk) 15:13, April 14, 2015 (UTC) I don't think it's about who would be a "better" rollback to be honest. — Spydar007 (Talk) 15:18, April 14, 2015 (UTC) TNK, whether Penguin-Pal is an admin currently is irrelevant - the discussion still should have been read and my reasoning would have provided the reverters with a clearer idea of why I was "warring". I am sorry you have a huge ego which provides you with the overwhelming fault to say you are right all the time. It is not a quality that should be cultivated. I also would like to tell you that you are not my parent. I do not have to do anything here. I do not have to listen to the admins. Not doing so would lead to a block, sure, and thus it is in my interests to do so, but I do not have to. I ignored and Ember you because you have absolutely no jurisdiction here, and especially none over me. — Spydar007 (Talk) 15:15, April 14, 2015 (UTC) Spydar, if you have an attitude like that then you're not going to become a rollback. You'll listen to the admins or leave, because we have a policy here, and if you don't like it then I cannot help you. Your comment is so ridiculously selfish it's actually funny. And Stick, I really don't see what your argument is here. Honestly, I'm not even going to bother, because the first part of your comment makes absolute zero sense towards what I said. And I don't want to be a rollback, and never said I wanted to be one, your comment is pointless. TheNintendoKing Don't care. You act like you're the babysitter/parent toward him, yet you act like a child sometimes yourself! Even more, your icon is Gollum. That makes NO sense in ANY way. Close to end of school... What to do? (Talk) 15:22 April 14, 2015 Stick, you are hands down one of the most immature people I've ever met. It does not matter if my icon is Gollum, because who cares? It makes perfect sense. I want a Gollum avatar so I have a Gollum avatar. Please don't go whining and crying just because you know what someone said to you is right, but that is honestly all you ever do. TheNintendoKing Try telling that to perapin. Anyways, It seems your the most immature person I'VE ever met. Your attempts of stopping Spydar from being a Rollback is proving futile. Seriously, you're the one who's causing the most drama now-a days. You need to STOP. Close to the end of school... What to do? (talk) 16:01, April 14, 2015 (UTC) What attitude? As I've already told Callum and people on IRC, I don't care for rights. I simply edit, and make the wiki as correct as possible (which was exactly what I was doing in the edit war case here). If people want me to have rights, fine. If not, fine. I don't need them to be a good editor here. Again, I did listen to the admins, as explained in my above comment. As soon as I was told to stop by an admin I stopped. You are not an admin.As I said before (and I will say it again because you still seem to be acting like you're my parent), you have no jurisdiction here, and especially none over me. — Spydar007 (Talk) 15:29, April 14, 2015 (UTC) You didn't stop when an admin told you. Watatsuki told you, he is an admin, you need to listen to him, yet you ignored him. There is no 'admin edit', he changed something you wrote so you don't change it back. TheNintendoKing As I said above, if he made it as an admin, does that mean that all edits made by admins are made as admins, and thus nobody can revert any admins edits, even if it is clearly incorrect? — Spydar007 (Talk) 15:38, April 14, 2015 (UTC) No, an edit made by an admin is no different than an edit made by you. It is possible to undo edits made by an admin. TNK is correct there is no 'admin' edit. :P -- S h u r o w 21:21, April 14, 2015 (UTC) I didn't mean to spark an entire debate with my comment. Please end it here or continue it on a talk page. --Hey.youcp 23:06, April 14, 2015 (UTC)

• I've decided to vote "for" since I think he could utilize the rollback right well, and I see that he's reverted some vandalism earlier today. I only ask that Spydar keep in mind what I said before and avoid getting into edit wars again. --Hey.youcp 23:06, April 14, 2015 (UTC)

EmberPrismDX (-3)

Nominated by EmberPrismDX and confirmed by Hey.youcp.

EmberPrismDX (talk · blog · contribs · block · logs · block log · rights log)

Against (3)

1. FuzzyHamster talk 22:34, April 14, 2015 (UTC)
2. I am Sasquatch's sock! Mwahahahaha 14:06, April 15, 2015 (UTC)
3. 
   Chriskim98

   • Talk Page
   • Contribs
   • Blogs
   16:00, April 18, 2015 (UTC)

Comments

• I would like a reason to vote for ember. FuzzyHamster talk 22:34, April 14, 2015 (UTC)
  • Well, I've undone vandalism a few times, I edit frequently and I have an editing experience, and I'm really interested in getting the Rollback right. I can handle the rights well. But for now, I'd like to be a Rollback without CM rights, I would prefer to get CM rights in the future, probably a few months after I get temp CM rights for the CM Calendar. April Flowers bloom in patterns! 23:43, April 14, 2015 (UTC)
    • An editing experience doesn't mean a good editing experience. I think Spydar would handle the tool well. FuzzyHamster talk 21:09, April 16, 2015 (UTC)
      • But Fuzzy, I've been on this wiki for a few months now and I undo vandalism frequently. I wouldn't abuse them and I can handle them pretty well! April Flowers bloom in patterns! 21:24, April 16, 2015 (UTC)
        • Few months versus few years — Spydar007 (Talk) 06:43, April 18, 2015 (UTC)
          • But Callum got promoted back a few months/weeks after he joined. His first promotion was back last year during January for the CM Calendar, I don't see why I wouldn't get promoted earlier just like Callum! April Flowers bloom in patterns! 13:28, April 18, 2015 (UTC)
            • Because Callum is actually a good editor? — Spydar007 (Talk) 15:22, April 18, 2015 (UTC)
              • Spydar, look at my contributions, I've undone vandalism too, and I said this a couple of times already! April Flowers bloom in patterns! 15:41, April 18, 2015 (UTC)
                • I'm afraid this is irrelevant in the current discussion. Undoing vandalism doesn't mean promotion to rollback. — Spydar007 (Talk) 15:43, April 18, 2015 (UTC)
      • Fuzzy, if you can think of more users who would be good rollbacks, please nominate them. --Hey.youcp 21:41, April 16, 2015 (UTC)
        • Sorry. My comment has now been changed. FuzzyHamster talk 22:00, April 17, 2015 (UTC)
          • Do you guys both understand that Spydar participates in edit wars too?! April Flowers bloom in patterns! 22:08, April 17, 2015 (UTC)
            • I suggest you read what I said in my nomination above if you really still think I do. — Spydar007 (Talk) 06:43, April 18, 2015 (UTC)
• No [for now] I am Sasquatch's sock! Mwahahahaha 14:06, April 15, 2015 (UTC)